A/B Email Testing | Madison Digital Email Marketing Agency

Email Marketing A/B Testing

If you’re not testing your emails, you’re guessing. A/B testing takes the uncertainty out of email marketing and helps you confidently send content your audience actually responds to.
At Craft My Campaign, we set up data-driven A/B tests that go beyond just changing a subject line. From email timing to visuals to CTAs, we help you learn what works — and improve performance over time.
 

Why A/B Testing Matters

Boosts Open Rates

Test different subject lines or sender names to find what gets attention.

Increases Clicks & Engagement

Discover what layout, offer, or call-to-action drives more action.

Reduces Unsubscribes

Send emails that feel more relevant and less disruptive.

Improves Conversions

Optimize every element to guide your audience toward the goal.

Informs Future Campaigns

Learn from every test to refine your voice, style, and strategy.

What We Test (and Why)

  • Email Marketing Agency Subject Line Testing

    Subject Lines

    We test different subject line styles to see what captures attention best — short vs. long, curiosity-driven vs. direct, with or without emojis. These variations help increase open rates and set the tone for the message inside.

  • Email Marketing Agency Send Time Testing

    Send Times & Days

    Timing can make or break engagement. We experiment with different days of the week and time slots to find when your audience is most likely to open and act on your emails.

  • Email Marketing Agency Email Copy Testing

    Email Copy & Tone

    We explore whether a casual, friendly tone or a more polished, professional voice performs better. We also test message length to strike the right balance between informative and digestible.

  • Email Marketing Agency Call To Action Testing

    Call-to-Action Buttons

    Small changes to your CTA — like the wording, color, or where it appears — can lead to big differences in clicks. We test multiple versions to find the most compelling combination.

  • Email Marketing Agency Design Testing

    Design Layouts

    Visual structure impacts how readers engage. We test different layouts, such as image-heavy vs. text-focused or single-column vs. multi-column, to improve readability and response.

  •  Email Marketing Agency Offer Testing

    Offer Types

    We evaluate which incentives drive the most conversions — percentage discounts, dollar-off deals, or free shipping. The right offer can significantly increase click-through and purchase rates.

Why Craft My Campaign?

We don’t test just for the sake of testing — every A/B experiment we run is purposeful, data-driven, and aligned with your business goals. Our approach is designed to simplify your strategy, not complicate it, so you get clear, actionable insights that actually improve performance.

From subject lines to send times, we help you make confident decisions backed by real results. No more debating which headline or layout might work — we’ll test it, measure it, and know for sure.

Get In Touch